Current Event #3: Future Progress: Should we Save or Destroy Ancient Site?
Due: Friday, September 28th, 2012
Mining
operation threatens Buddhist icons
Recently,
our class has been covering the histories of ancient river valley
civilizations of the past. We’ve studied how each civilization must
exhibit certain criteria or key features in order to be considered
one of importance. As you reflect on these lessons, imagine the world
today minus the great pyramids of Egypt along with a host of other
monuments and natural wonders of the present world. This week, our
current event focuses on the topic of saving an ancient site from
being destroyed by economical progression. As you read the article,
learn of how a Buddhist statue overlooks a Chinese government-owned
mining compound in Logar province, Afghanistan. Mes
Aynak, a
2,600-year-old Buddhist site, could be destroyed in December to
create a massive copper mine.
Brent
Huffman,
a documentary filmmaker and assistant professor at the Medill School
of Journalism at Northwestern University,
documents that the
ancient site will be destroyed by plans to mine the area. A Chinese
company has granted permission to create a massive open-pit style
copper mine, whereas Huffman states that Mes
Aynak is a missing
link showing Afghanistan's historic role in Asia. He further states
that destroying Mes
Aynak is equivalent to
wiping Machu Picchu
off the map. How do you feel about destroying historical
landmarks/sites in the wake of promoting future progression?
What
You Will Do?
- First, read the article outlining the case surrounding a historical landmark in Afghanistan. After reading the article begin thinking about one historic landmark/monument that exist in the world today in order to answer the questions below.
- State by name the historical landmark/monument that comes to your mind and explain its significance to the world and/or group of people in which it represents.
- Analyze why you might or might not be in favor of moving forward with future progress that would lead to the destruction of structures holding significant histories tied to a land/people.
- Evaluate the impact of losing your historical landmark/monument of choice would have on our society?
***Note: Be sure to write complete, detailed sentences in paragraph form, when you share your responses to the blog.