Current Event # 3:
How Should Society Deal With Lawbreakers?
Due: Friday, 9/30/2011
The question of how to deal fairly and effectively with lawbreakers is as old as society itself. To begin your own investigation, examine the following viewpoints.
Babylon 1790s B.C.
The Code of Hammurabi calls for strict justice:
"If a son strike his father, his hands shall be cut off. If a man put out the eye of another man, his eye shall be put out. If he break another man's bone, his bone shall be broken....If a man knock out the teeth of his equal, his teeth shall be knocked out."
Italy 1764
Cesare Beccaria was one of the first reformers to argue against torture, capital punishment, and harsh treatment of criminals:
"The purpose [of punishment] can only be to prevent the criminal from inflicting new injuries on its citizens and to deter others from similar acts....Such punishments and such methods of inflicting them ought to be chosen, therefore, which will make the strongest and most lasting impression on the minds of men, and inflict the least torment on the body of the criminal."
Singapore 1994
In 1994, an American teenager living in Singapore was sentenced to a painful flogging for acts of vandalism. An official defended his country's harsh penalties.
"Unlike some other societies which tolerate acts of vandalism, Singapore has its own standards of social order as reflected in our laws. We are able to keep Singapore relatively crime-free. We do not have a situation where acts of vandalism are commonplace, as in cities like New York, where even police cars are not spared."
You will need to:
Research and post a link of a fairly recent news story, detailing a crime involving someone or an organization quilty of breaking a law(s). Be sure to provide the clear specifics of the case and what law(s) was/were broken. Discuss at length, in detail, how you agree or disagree with the punishment given for the crime(s) committed. Within your response, provide strong reasons to support your argument as to whether you feel the justice system failed or supported those involved.
Be sure to include the following in your blog post:
-Your name/class period
-Title of article/author
-Source/date of article
-URL (copy and paste your article link in your response for me to review your article)
Paragraph #1:
-Summary of your selected article (minimum of 6-7 sentences that provide detail about who/what, when, where, and why your current event is significant)
Paragraph #2:
-Reflection/Opinion of article (minimum of 3 sentences)
-Give supporting facts and include any personal experiences associated with the article